I know you never read Voltaire. And if you did, it wasn't the entitled piece. It is a short satire about the senses. Beings that have many compared to our few. They pitied us. The senses allowed them to know the world across many scales simultaneously. Unlike we humans.
As the metaphor that biology and more importantly our bodies are
machines fades into history, our understanding about the organization
and function of our bodies as nonlinear systems grow. But practices
related to health, from medicine to exercise still largely ignore this
fact and people engage in those practices without recognizing that the
so-called 'facts' that formed the foundation of those practices are no
longer true. While the persistence of memory constrains most people and
their practices, some innovators are developing new practices, from
medicine, exercise and diet to interpersonal relationships and group
functioning. Broadly, these 'system' based practices entail aligning
those practices with the complex functioning of bodies. There are new
metaphors that better describe the complex, nonlinear, systems
functioning of our bodies. By complex, we mean many simultaneous,
interdependent processes are always happening and they are iterative,
meaning the output of one process is a partial input to itself and other
processes. This collective is a non-linear system, where the 'size' of
the inputs are not directly correlated with the degree or size of the
output. Small inputs can have large effects and large inputs can have
negligible effects. One common feature of these kinds of nonlinear
systems, biological or otherwise, is something called 'scalar
invariance.' This means that relationships and/or structures are highly
similar no matter the scale at which they are viewed. Like a tree to a
branch to a twig, they have the same structures across all those
scales, constituting a 'fractal.'
For us, this is a fundamental property of humans and especially human
health. In the old metaphor, human health was about machine
maintenance. Isolated, compartmentalized, virtually independent
sub-systems interacting in very specific ways. But the body is not a
set of separate systems, but an active community of self which can only
function as a complete unit. Like other fractals, we can see that what
people take for health, meaning the ability to function readily and
easily in everyday life, is only at one level of resolution, the
'eyeball' level. But investigate across scale, to systems, organs,
tissues, the very cells themselves and you will find a similar level of
'health,' the whole body functions as robustly or as poorly as the
organs function, so too tissues and finally cells. Health is the same
at all scales.
Interventions have been designed at the level of the body, say exercise,
which does translate to improved cellular function, i.e. exercise
engages the body across scale, or much more narrow interventions, like
drugs, that are designed to effect, in general, some specific cellular
activity. That kind of intervention can and does have effects at other
scales, but is not aimed specifically at health, but at disease.
Directly addressing the cellular function, liken that to cellular health
and the inter-cellular milieu, think of that as the culture and
influence cells have on each other, begins to get at the generation of
health from the cell up, through the other levels of health and finally
even to interpersonal healthy functioning.
Another core feature of biological systems, unlike machines, is timing.
Our bodies are not the same over time. Not in birth, adulthood and
old age, and not in summer and winter and not in day and night.
Different systems are in use, different genes are being transcribed,
different behavior, from cells to our whole body are taking place. Most
interventions, whether cellular or behavioral, simply ignore this
biological fact. Fitting intervention to the best time is as critical
as fitting it to the best scale.
In the same way that our bodies function across scales and time, so do
interventions that are most empathic to the challenge. Design the
proper intervention, from exercise to supplements to mediation aimed at
the right scale, from cells to selves and deliver them at the right
time, day or night, summer or winter. Then we can begin to rebuild
health and wellness in its own organic image and leave the ancient
machinery behind.